BLUEPRINT

Advertiser Disclosure

Editorial Note: Blueprint may earn a commission from affiliate partner links featured here on our site. This commission does not influence our editors' opinions or evaluations. Please view our full advertiser disclosure policy.

ManyPets and Pets Best have the best pet insurance in Colorado, according to our analysis of cost and coverage.

The best pet insurance companies in Colorado

Why trust our insurance experts

Our team of experts evaluates hundreds of insurance products and analyzes thousands of data points to help you find the best product for your situation. We use a data-driven methodology to determine each rating. Advertisers do not influence our editorial content. You can read more about our methodology below.

  • 30 Colorado pet insurance rates reviewed.
  • 324 coverage details evaluated.
  • 5 levels of fact-checking.

Top-rated pet insurance companies in Colorado of 2023

Compare the best pet insurance companies in Colorado

Here’s how Colorado pet insurance companies compare.

CompanyColorado ratingAverage monthly costLEARN MORE
ManyPets5 stars$28$500Unlimited80%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Pets Best5 stars$35$50, $100, $200, $250, $500 or $1,000$5,000 or unlimited70%, 80% or 90%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Embrace4.5 stars$65$100, $250, $500, $750 or $1,000$5,000, $8,000, $10,000, $15,000 or unlimited70%, 80%, 90%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Figo4.5 stars$40$100, $250, $500 or $750$5,000, $10,000 or Unlimited70%, 80%, 90%, 100%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Lemonade4.5 stars$20$100, $250 or $500$5,000, $10,000, $20,000, $50,000 or $100,00070%, 80%, 90%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Fetch4 stars$39$300, $500 or $700$5,000, $10,000 or $15,00070%, 80%, 90%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Healthy Paws4 stars$34$100, $250 or $500Unlimited70%, 80%, 90%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
MetLife3.5 stars$58$50, $100, $250 or $500$2,000, $5,000 or $10,00070%, 80%, 90%Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Trupanion3.5 stars$67UnlimitedCompare RatesVia Petted’s Website

Average monthly premiums assume unlimited reimbursement (or the highest level offered by that company), a $500 deductible and a 90% reimbursement percentage.

Methodology

We analyzed nine pet insurance companies operating in Colorado using data from Petinsurer.com.

For this analysis, average rates are based on accident and illness plans, which account for 98% of pet insurance policies purchased, according to data from the North American Health Pet Insurance Association (NAPHIA). Rates are also based on insuring dogs, as dogs make up 85% of insured pets, per NAPHIA.

Each pet insurance company was eligible for up to 100 points, based on its performance in the following key categories:

Cost: 50 points. We calculated average rates for accident and illness pet insurance plans for a medium-sized, mixed-breed dog at two different ages in Colorado, with unlimited annual reimbursement (or the highest level offered by that company), a $250 deductible and a 90% reimbursement percentage. The lower the average rate, the higher the number of points.

Annual coverage limits: 10 points. Pet insurance companies that offer annual reimbursement of up to $100,000, or unlimited annual coverage scored in this category.

24/7 vet line: 10 points. Insurance companies that offer access to a 24/7 vet line earned points. Being able to call for medical advice might save you money on vet visits.

Routine wellness plan: 10 points. Pet insurance companies that offer an optional wellness plan add-on scored points. Wellness plans can reimburse you for preventative care for your pet.

Pays vet exam fees: 10 points. If a pet insurance plan includes pet exam fees, the insurer received 10 points. If this is offered as a coverage add on, the insurer received 5 points.

Behavioral therapy: 5 points. If an insurance company covers behavior therapy in its pet insurance plans, it scored points.

Euthanasia or end of life expenses included: 5 points. If euthanasia or other end of life expenses are covered in pet insurance plans, an insurance company scored in this category.

Compare the best pet insurance rates in Colorado

Here’s how much the best pet insurance companies in Colorado cost on average. 

Colorado pet insurance cost with $5,000 annual maximum coverage

CompanyMonthly cost LEARN MORE
Lemonade$10Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Figo$28Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Fetch$32Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Embrace$46Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Healthy PawsCompare RatesVia Petted’s Website
ManyPetsCompare RatesVia Petted’s Website

Source: PetInsurer.com. Monthly rates are for a plan with a $5,000 annual coverage maximum), a $250 deductible ($200 for Embrace) and 90% reimbursement level.

Colorado pet insurance cost with unlimited annual maximum coverage

CompanyMonthly costLEARN MORE
Lemonade$20Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
ManyPets$28Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Healthy Paws$34Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Fetch$39Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Figo$40Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website
Embrace$65Compare RatesVia Petted’s Website

Source: PetInsurer.com. Monthly rates are for a plan with unlimited annual coverage ($30,000 for Embrace and $100,000 for Lemonade), a $250 deductible ($200 for Embrace) and 90% reimbursement level.

What is pet insurance?

Pet insurance is a plan that pays a portion of eligible veterinary costs in exchange for a monthly or annual premium.

How much you pay for pet insurance will depend on a number of factors, including:

  • Your pet’s age, breed and species. 
  • Your pet’s size and gender. 
  • Your Colorado ZIP code. Living in a more rural area like Leadville, Rifle or Pagosa Springs might mean you pay less for pet insurance than Coloradans in Aurora, Denver and Colorado Springs.
  • The pet insurance company, plan and coverage options you choose.

Types of pet insurance plans

When comparing pet insurance options, you can choose from an accident and illness plan or an accident-only plan. Depending on the pet insurance company, you may also have the option to add a wellness plan.

Accident and illness. Offering the broadest range of coverage, this comprehensive pet insurance covers both accidents and illnesses. It will cover everything an accident-only plan will, plus breed-specific, chronic and hereditary conditions, heart disease and other illnesses.

Accident-only. This plan is usually cheaper than a comprehensive plan because it excludes treatment for sickness. Accidents include broken bones and teeth, insect or animal bites, ingested poisons, bloat and lacerations. Accident-only coverage may pay for associated costs of hospitalization, surgery, diagnostic testing and prescription medications.

Routine wellness plan. A wellness plan will cover routine and preventative care and is usually available as an add-on to an accident and illness insurance policy. Veterinary expenses to maintain your pet’s health aren’t covered under pet insurance without a wellness plan. This typically includes annual visit fees, microchipping, vaccinations, spay or neuter surgery and dental cleanings.

Learn more: Pet dental insurance explained

How does pet insurance work?

When you buy pet insurance, you can choose from different levels of coverage, deductible and reimbursement level. The more the insurer reimburses, the higher your premiums will be. Consider these options when comparing pet insurance policies.

Annual maximum limit

The annual maximum coverage limit is the most the insurer will pay per plan year. Most carriers offer an annual cap between $5,000 to unlimited. 

Deductible

Before the insurer will reimburse for covered vet expenses, you have to meet a deductible. Pet insurance companies offer deductibles typically from $50 to $1,000. You can save on your premium by having a higher deductible, but you’ll also have to foot more costs on your own. 

Reimbursement percentage

Once you’ve met your deductible, the insurance company begins reimbursing for eligible expenses. The reimbursement percentage is the portion of each bill your insurer will pay. Most insurance companies offer 70%, 80% or 90% reimbursement. Figo is the only carrier in our lineup offering 100% reimbursement.

How to find the best pet insurance in Colorado

When searching for the best pet insurance in Colorado, consider these features to help you choose a carrier and plan.

24/7 vet lines

A 24/7 vet line is available through many pet insurance companies and is staffed by experienced veterinary experts. Most vet lines are available through chat or over the phone, answering general questions about your pet’s health to provide guidance for the best healthcare solutions. If your pet has a medical issue in the middle of the night and your vet’s office is closed, the 24/7 vet line may help you avoid an unnecessary and costly emergency vet visit.

Direct pay option

Some vet offices are directly linked to pet insurance companies. This software connection allows the veterinarian to submit your pet’s invoice electronically so you only pay your portion at checkout, instead of paying in full, then filing a claim and waiting for reimbursement.

Check for discounts

If you own more than one pet, most pet insurers will offer a multi-pet discount ranging from 5% to 10% on each additional policy. There may also be discounts for military members and workers in certain organizations or membership affiliations. Some pet insurance companies, like Embrace, offer a diminishing deductible feature, which lowers your deductible for each policy year you don’t file a claim.

Wellness plan rider option 

Pet insurance only covers certain vet expenses for accidents and illnesses. Routine and preventative care, like vaccinations and flea and tick preventatives, will help keep your pet healthy and can extend its life expectancy. Consider pet insurance companies offering preventive care coverage.

Pet health considerations in Colorado

Colorado is one of the most pet-friendly states in the country, according to a study by Safewise. It’s also one of the best states to live in for your pet’s health. However, pets are still at risk for injuries and illnesses in Colorado. 

Sun and elevation

With an abundance of sunshine and high elevation, your pet is more susceptible to sunburn, especially if your pet is a light color or a hairless breed. Pets are also at risk for skin cancer on their noses and tips of their ears, even if you’re diligent about covering them in sunscreen. 

The sun can also cause an eye disorder called Pannus, which mainly affects German Shepherds, but can also affect other dog breeds. Corticosteroid shots and eye drops can control Pannus, but not cure this cornea disease. Pannus is most common in Colorado, as is the autoimmune disorder Lupus. Colorado pets are especially susceptible to discoid lupus erythematosus (DLE), which attacks the skin.

Mountain adventures

One benefit of living in Colorado is all the outdoor activities you can enjoy in the mountains, such as hiking, camping, skiing and snowshoeing. If you take your dog along for the adventure, it could end up with paw injuries from the rocky terrain or giardia from drinking tainted water from lakes, rivers or streams. Although most injuries can heal after proper veterinary care, giardia intestine infections can be treated, but not cured.

You also have to consider the abundance of wildlife your pet could face in Colorado. Coyotes, bears, porcupines and mountain lions are just a few of the animals that could cause devastating injuries to your furry companion.

There are also tiny predators waiting to infect your pet with diseases. Colorado is home to several tick species, including Rocky Mountain wood ticks and the American dog tick. Ticks can transmit Colorado tick fever, Rocky Mountain spotted fever, Lyme disease and Tularemia to your pet. 

With pet insurance in place, before you take your companion into the Colorado sun and wilderness, these injuries and illnesses won’t be considered pre-existing conditions. It’s always a good idea to get pet insurance when your pet is at its healthiest, so you get the most use out of your plan coverage.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Yes, it’s worth shopping around for pet insurance. Just like auto, home and life insurance for humans, pet insurance costs can vary by company. Getting pet insurance quotes is quick and easy online, so it won’t take long to gather them for comparison to find the best price for your pet’s insurance needs.

Learn more: How to compare pet insurance quotes

Only you can decide if a monthly pet plan is worth it. As your pet ages, it’s more likely to need veterinary care, which can be costly. Comparing the price of pet insurance and how much you could spend on vet expenses can help you decide if pet insurance is worth it. For example, if your pet develops cancer, it costs around $4,000 to treat. A broken bone can cost around $2,500, while a bladder infection or UTI could cost anywhere from $400 to $1,100.

Learn more: Is pet insurance worth it?

Even if you get pet insurance, it’s a good idea to put money aside for your pet’s veterinary expenses. Pet insurance doesn’t cover everything, and you’ll still have a deductible and reimbursement percentage to pay. Having money set aside can help you pay for an unexpected accident or illness without it affecting your family’s budget.

Learn more: How much does a dog cost per year?

Yes, pet insurance does get more expensive with age. The older your pet gets, the more health problems it could face, which can drive up the cost of pet insurance. Getting pet insurance before your pet develops age-related conditions can ensure it won’t be considered a pre-existing condition, which wouldn’t be covered.

Learn more: Best cheap pet insurance 

Blueprint is an independent publisher and comparison service, not an investment advisor. The information provided is for educational purposes only and we encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding specific financial decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Blueprint has an advertiser disclosure policy. The opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the Blueprint editorial staff alone. Blueprint adheres to strict editorial integrity standards. The information is accurate as of the publish date, but always check the provider’s website for the most current information.

Mandy Sleight

BLUEPRINT

Mandy is an insurance writer who has been creating online content since 2018. Before becoming a full-time freelance writer, Mandy spent 15 years working as an insurance agent. Her work has been published in Bankrate, MoneyGeek, The Insurance Bulletin, U.S. News and more.

Kara McGinley

BLUEPRINT

Kara McGinley is deputy editor of insurance at USA TODAY Blueprint and a licensed home insurance expert. Previously, she was a senior editor at Policygenius, where she specialized in homeowners and renters insurance. Her work and insights have been featured in MSN, Lifehacker, Kiplinger, PropertyCasualty360 and more.